Customer Reviews
Trusted since 2023 with thousands of successful transactions. See what real customers have to say.
See Why Sellers Choose Sell My Games
Every review below comes from a real seller who went through the full process. Here's what the numbers look like.
What Sellers Are Saying
Real feedback from customers who have sold games, consoles, and accessories through Sell My Games.
Payment was prompt and exactly what I expected given the online offer. Submitting the items using the online form was easy, and shipping was free. No complaints at all. I highly recommend using sellmygames.com.
Roland
Awesome experience with this company for selling my console and games. The prices are fair, and the games they buy are good choices as well. Customer service is very quick and very easy to understand as well! Thank you very much CaveGamers/Sell My Games! Highly Recommended!
Ethan Kirkman
I had a great experience with you guys. The shipping was simple, quick and efficient. I received the amount that i was promised. If you have any tech laying around, you could make real money by selling them to sellmygames.com.
Jason O Hudson
I fully expected not to get what was offered but some excuse as to why I would not get the full value quoted. I'm impressed with the web site and how easy it was to sell some games and a console.
Jack Olson
100% recommend, amazing company! Amazing so grateful how the service was. Get paid very well. Definitely recommend this company if you're trading in anything. Use PayPal for payment method to get paid, you'll get paid in seconds!
Ben Jester
Quick...Fast...Easy Transaction...actually gave me more money because I put down the wrong Playstation 3 system...HONESTY....I like that...Respect that.
Thomas Porga
The process of selling my video games and consoles has been so simple and fast. It was simple to receive a quote and anything that differed in the final price was clearly explained and very fair.
Trey Schober
The whole process was easy and fast. The prices were fair in my opinion and I had the money in my account four days after I shipped my games off. I can easily recommend Sell My Games as a great place to unload your old games for some extra cash.
Mark Hicks
What Customers Highlight Most
Fast payouts
Quick payment and a smooth finish once orders are delivered and finalized.
Easy shipping
Prepaid labels and a simple order flow make it easy to box up items and send them in.
Fair offers
Clear pricing, transparent condition standards, and a process that feels straightforward.
Helpful support
Questions before or after shipping are handled by a real team that knows the products and the process.
Want to understand the full process? Visit How It Works or review our condition guidelines.
Verified on Trustpilot
Independent, unfiltered reviews you can verify yourself. This is what selling to Sell My Games looks like from the customer side.
Ready to Get Your Quote?
Search your items, lock in your offer, and ship for free.
Get Your Instant QuoteStill have questions? Contact us and we will help before you ship.