How It Works

Search for your items and instantly see your cash offer based on current market value. We buy over 25,000 unique items, so chances are yours is on the list. Use filters to narrow by category or system. Can't find something? Let us know and we'll add it. Quotes reflect current market prices, and deductions apply for poor condition, missing parts, functionality issues, or dirty items.

Review your cart, ensure you're at the $25 minimum, then enter your info and select a payment method. Choose from Venmo, PayPal, check, or CaveGamers store credit (with a 10% bonus).

We'll email you a prepaid USPS label. Pack securely with cushioning, secure the label on top, and drop off at USPS or scan the QR code to schedule a free pickup.

Multiple boxes? Create separate orders or contact us for extra labels.

In Sioux Falls? Schedule a drop-off at our warehouse.

We test everything and check condition. If we need to adjust your total by more than 10%, we'll email a revised offer. You decide whether to accept or have us return your items (you cover return shipping). Otherwise, we process payment right away. Most payments arrive within 1-2 business days after delivery. If you choose a check, allow about 10 business days for it to reach you by mail.

+10% bonus

Common Questions

Do I need to test everything before shipping?
Nope! We test it all when it arrives and adjust pricing based on our Deductions policy.

Can I sell games without the box or manual?
Yes. You can flag missing cases in your cart and the 20% deduction adjusts your quote automatically.

What if my console is missing cords?
No problem. We deduct $8 for missing power cord or $4 for missing HDMI/video cable.

What if I disagree with a revised offer?
You can accept the adjusted total or have us return your items. You're never locked in.