Sell My Games
Search for games to start adding items
Order must be over $25 to submit
Get More Than GameStop Offers
Fast quotes, free shipping, and secure payouts. No store hassle.
Get Your Instant QuoteWhy Choose Us Over GameStop?
- Higher Payouts – Real-time market pricing, not capped buyback rates.
- No Membership Required – Get our best prices without a paid subscription. GameStop reserves top trade values for Pro members.
- Sell From Home – Print a free shipping label and drop off at USPS. No driving to a store, no waiting in line.
- Full Price Transparency – See your exact quote before you ship, with published deduction guidelines so there are no surprises.
- Flexible Payments – Venmo, PayPal, check, or 10% extra CaveGamers credit. Cash options from day one.
Compare Our Offers to GameStop
| Item | Sell My Games | GameStop |
|---|---|---|
| Wii Sports – Nintendo Wii | $29.00 | $10.50 |
| Pokémon Crystal – Game Boy Color | $101.00 | $10.50 |
| Nintendo Switch | $105.00 | $56.00 |
| The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom – Switch | $17.00 | $14.00 |
*Prices are updated periodically and are subject to change. See GameStop values. Items may also be subject to condition-based deductions.
How It Works
- Get a Quote: Search for your items and instantly see what we'll pay.
- Ship for Free: Print a prepaid USPS label and send your items.
- Get Paid: Payment within 48 hours after inspection.
Common Questions
In most cases, yes. Our offers are based on real-time market data, so they reflect what items are actually worth.
GameStop cash trade-in values are often well below market value. Check the comparison table to see current examples,
or search for your items to see your personalized quote.
Yes. Every order includes a prepaid, trackable USPS shipping label at no cost to you.
Just pack your items, attach the label, and drop off at any USPS location.
We process payments within 48 hours of receiving and inspecting your items.
Venmo and PayPal payments arrive the same day they are sent. Checks take about 10 days by mail.
We offer Venmo, PayPal, check by mail, or CaveGamers store credit with a 10% bonus.
You choose your preferred method when placing your order.
We still accept most items. Deductions may apply for damage, missing parts, or excessive dirt.
If deductions exceed 10% of the quoted total, we will email you a revised offer before processing payment.
Have more questions? See our full FAQ page or contact us.
Real Customer Reviews
Still deciding? Hear from sellers who made the switch.